Rocking pavers and stones
Fix soon
What you notice. A paver or flagstone clunks or tips when you step on one edge, often
with sand missing from the joints around it.
Likely causesA soft or hollow spot underneath. With pavers it is usually bedding sand that was laid too thick or unevenly, a base that was not compacted, or sand washed out through open joints. With mortar-set flagstone it is voids left by dabs of mortar instead of a full bed.
How seriousNot structural on its own, but it never stops by itself. Every rock grinds the joints open, more water gets in and the movement spreads.
RemedyPry the paver out, check the base under it is firm (tamp and add gravel if not), rescreed the roughly 1 in of bedding sand level with the neighbors, set the paver, tap it down with a rubber mallet and re-sand the joints. For flagstone, clean off the old mortar and reset on a full bed. Pounding it harder without lifting it does nothing.
Loose flagstones and tiles
Fix soon
What you notice. A mortared flagstone or porcelain paver lifts out cleanly, sometimes
with the mortar still stuck to the slab below instead of the stone.
Likely causesThe stone never bonded. Common with dense porcelain set without a bond coat, stone with a dusty back, mortar that had started to stiffen before the stone went down, or a concrete slab underneath that moves in frost.
How seriousA trip hazard more than a structural fault, but a warning: if one let go for that reason, others were probably set the same way.
RemedyChip off the old mortar, clean the back of the stone and the bed, apply a bonding slurry or thinset to the back of the stone, and reset on fresh mortar. Grout the joints once it has cured.
Cracked pavers, stones and concrete
Fix soon
What you notice. A crack through a single paver or flagstone, or a line running across a
concrete patio, sometimes with one side a little higher.
Likely causesFor pavers and stone, a heavy point load (grill, planter, ladder foot) over a soft spot. For poured concrete, drying shrinkage, control joints spaced too far apart, a poorly compacted base, frost heave or tree roots.
How seriousA single cracked paver is a nuisance. Hairline cracks in concrete are normal. A crack wider than about 1/4 in, with an offset or still widening, points to movement below.
RemedyReplace a cracked paver or stone and firm up the base while it is out, which is exactly why you keep a few spares from the original pallet. Seal narrow concrete cracks with a flexible concrete crack filler to keep water out; slabs with large offset cracks may need mudjacking, foam lifting or replacement.
Uneven surface and trip edges
Trip hazard
What you notice. Neighboring pavers at different heights, so a chair leg catches or a toe
snags. Usually worst along the outer edge or at a step.
Likely causesUneven settlement, missing or failed edge restraint letting the edge pavers spread and drop, roots lifting the surface, or pavers that were never set level in the first place.
How seriousCosmetic until someone falls. A lip of more than about 1/4 in on a walking route is worth fixing promptly.
RemedyLift the high or low pavers and relay them to a straightedge. Reinstall or add edge restraint spiked into the base. If roots are doing the lifting, decide about the tree before cutting anything big, and get an arborist's opinion for large trees.
Sunken areas
Structural
What you notice. A shallow bowl covering several pavers or part of a slab, usually holding
water and slowly getting worse.
Likely causesThe base or the soil under it settling: gravel base too thin or not compacted in 2 to 3 in lifts, topsoil or roots left in place and rotting, sand and fines washing out, a backfilled utility or downspout trench, or soft clay that was paved over.
How seriousGenuinely structural. Relaying the surface without fixing what is under it usually buys a year or two.
RemedyLift the area, dig out the base, find the cause, then rebuild with compacted crushed stone (usually 4 to 6 in, more on clay or in cold regions) and relay. If water caused it, solve the water first. Sunken concrete slabs can sometimes be raised by mudjacking or polyurethane foam injection.
Movement by a wall or retaining wall
Get it checked
What you notice. Pavers dropping or lifting along the house or a wall, a retaining wall
leaning, or blocks pushing out behind a raised patio.
Likely causesWet soil behind a retaining wall with no drainage, backfill against the foundation that is still settling, or foundation movement.
How seriousPotentially very. Retaining walls tend to fail suddenly, and the forces behind them are large.
RemedySkip the cosmetic patch. Have a structural engineer or an experienced hardscape contractor look at it, and keep people and pets away from anything visibly leaning. Taller retaining walls often need a permit and engineering, so check locally.