Herb robert quick facts
About herb-robert
Geranium robertianum is a true wild geranium (a cranesbill), widespread across Europe and Asia. In North America its story is mixed: some botanists consider scattered populations in the Northeast and eastern Canada to be native, but most of the plants you meet, and certainly those on the West Coast, came from Europe. It is now found across much of the northern US.
In the Pacific Northwest it is a genuine invasive. It spreads through moist conifer forests, stream sides and shady yards, forming dense mats that crowd out native wildflowers and tree seedlings. Washington lists it as a noxious weed, and it is a major forest weed in western Oregon too. If you live in the region, pull it rather than encourage it, and check your county's weed list.
It is easy to recognize. The leaves are cut into three to five stalked lobes, each divided again, so they look ferny. Stems are thin, hairy and often bright red, and the whole plant can turn crimson in sun or drought. The pink flowers have five rounded petals with pale stripes and are followed by long, beak-like seed pods that snap open and fling seed several feet.
Crushed leaves smell sharp and unpleasant, which earned it the folk name "stinky Bob" and is one reason deer leave it alone. For a native wild geranium in the East, grow wild geranium (Geranium maculatum); in the Northwest, try fringecup, piggyback plant or western wild ginger.
Where it grows
Shade and disturbed ground. Knowing where it thrives tells you where to watch for it.
Shade
Part or full shade, including dry shade under shrubs and conifers. In full sun it turns red and seeds quickly.
Soil
Any soil from heavy clay to gravel, rotting logs and the mortar of old walls. It even sprouts in the top of potted plants.
Moisture
Average to dry. It does best in the cool, moist shade of Pacific Northwest forests.
Disturbed ground
Trails, roadsides, logged areas and freshly dug beds all give its seed a foothold.
Hardiness
Grows in USDA zones 4-8 (find your zone). Fall seedlings overwinter as small red-tinged rosettes.
How it travels
Seeds are flung from the pods and also stick to boots, pets, tires and nursery pots. That is how it moves into new woods.
Where to keep it out
Anywhere near woods or streams in the Pacific Northwest, plus rock gardens, new plantings and seed trays everywhere.
Where it is tolerable
In the East and Midwest, a few plants in a shady wall crack or gravel strip are rarely a problem, but pull them before they seed into woods.
Herb robert across the US
It grows in USDA zones 4-8, but how much of a problem it is depends heavily on your region.
Northeast & Midwest
Found in rocky woods, ravines and shady yards, usually in modest numbers. Pull it from beds and keep it out of natural areas. Grow native wild geranium, wild ginger or foamflower for shade instead.
Southeast & Gulf Coast
Uncommon in the hot, humid lowland South, where summers are too warm for it. It may turn up in cooler mountain areas. Native green-and-gold and wild geranium are better shade choices.
Southwest & California
Occasional in cool, shady coastal Northern California, where it can spread in redwood and mixed forest. Too hot and dry for it in most of the Southwest.
Pacific Northwest
Its worst region. A noxious weed in Washington and a widespread forest invader in western Oregon. Hand-pull before seed pods ripen, bag the plants, clean boots after hikes, and replant bare spots with natives such as fringecup and sword fern.
Mountain West & Plains
Rare in the dry interior. Watch for it in shady, irrigated yards and moist mountain valleys, and pull any plants you find.
How to remove herb-robert
Don't plant or sow it
There is no need to introduce it, and in the Pacific Northwest you should not. If it appears on its own, decide quickly whether it stays.
Pull before the pods ripen
Grab the plant at the base and lift; the roots are shallow and it comes out cleanly. Do it in spring and again in late summer.
Bag plants that are seeding
Put flowering or seeding plants in the trash, not the compost pile, where seeds may survive.
Cover the bare soil
Mulch cleared areas with wood chips or leaves and replant with native ground covers so new seedlings have less room.
Check for several years
Seed in the soil keeps sprouting for a few seasons. Regular quick sweeps clear a yard over time.
Managing herb-robert
The goal is to stop seed. Everything else follows from that.
Timing
Pull in early spring when rosettes are easy to spot, and again in midsummer before most pods ripen.
Stopping seed
Once the long beaked pods turn brown they spring open and scatter seed several feet. Pulling before that is what wins the battle.
Herbicides
Rarely needed for a home yard, since hand-pulling works well. For large forest infestations, follow your county weed board's advice.
Clean gear
Brush off boots, pets and tools after working in infested areas, and check nursery pots for seedlings before planting.
Replanting
Fill gaps with native shade plants so the ground isn't left open. Thick native ground cover is the best long-term defense.
Where you allow it
Outside the Northwest, if you let a few plants stay in an awkward wall crack, shear them after the first flush to cut seed.
Common problems & how to prevent them
It is coming up everywhere
Seedlings in beds, pots, gravel and paver joints.
Prevent: the exploding seed pods. Pull plants before pods ripen and mulch bare soil.It has spread into the woods
A green carpet under trees behind the yard.
Prevent: seed carried by boots, pets and water. Hand-pull, bag and replant with natives; in Washington and Oregon, ask your county weed board or conservation district for help.A strong smell when weeding
A sharp, musty odor on hands and gloves.
Prevent: oils in the leaves, released when crushed. Harmless, and it washes off. Gloves help.Bright red leaves
Whole plants turning crimson.
Prevent: a natural response to sun, drought or cold, not a disease. Red plants are just as easy to pull.Confusing it with natives
Worry about pulling the wrong plant.
Prevent: check for red stems, ferny stalked leaflets, small pink flowers and the strong smell. Native wild geranium has bigger, lilac flowers and broader leaves.Better plants for the same shade
Garden plants that fill the shady spots herb robert would otherwise claim.
Primrose
Primula vulgaris
Soft yellow spring flowers for moist shade.
View profileCommon dog violet
Viola riviniana
Small violet flowers in shady, poor ground. Native violets such as Viola sororia do the same and host fritillary butterflies.
View profileHart's Tongue Fern
Asplenium scolopendrium
Glossy evergreen fronds for shade; native Christmas fern or sword fern are easy US alternatives.
View profilePlants similar to herb-robert
Garden geraniums that give the same look without the weedy seeding.
Cranesbill Geranium
Geranium macrorrhizum
Bigroot geranium: tough, fragrant, semi-evergreen ground cover for dry shade, and deer resistant.
View profileGeranium sanguineum
Geranium sanguineum
Bloody cranesbill: magenta flowers on a tight, sun-loving mound.
View profileMeadow cranesbill
Geranium pratense
Tall violet-blue geranium for sunny beds and meadow-style plantings.
View profileHardy Geranium 'Johnson's Blue'
Geranium 'Johnson's Blue'
Lavender-blue, long-blooming border geranium.
View profileWildlife value
Some food for small insects, but in the Northwest it does far more harm than good.
Small bees and hover flies
The open flowers are visited by small native bees and hover flies over a long season.
Harm to native plants
Where it invades, its mats crowd out trilliums, native violets and other spring wildflowers that native bees and moths depend on.
Native geraniums do more
Wild geranium (Geranium maculatum) supports specialist native bees and is a strong nectar plant for spring.
Ground cover for wildlife
Native ground covers such as wild ginger, foamflower and sword fern give the same cool, damp cover for beetles, toads and salamanders.
Leave the leaves
After clearing herb Robert, a layer of fallen leaves feeds soil life and gives overwintering insects shelter, and still makes it harder for new seedlings to start.
Herb robert - frequently asked questions
Is herb robert invasive?
In the Pacific Northwest, yes. It is a listed noxious weed in Washington and spreads through forests in western Oregon and nearby areas. Elsewhere in the US it is usually a minor weed, but it should still be kept out of natural areas.
Is herb robert native to North America?
It is mainly a Eurasian plant. Some botanists treat a few populations in the Northeast and eastern Canada as native, but the plants spreading in the West were introduced from Europe.
How do I get rid of herb robert?
Hand-pull it before the seed pods ripen; the roots are shallow and it lifts easily. Bag seeding plants for the trash, mulch the bare soil, and check again each spring and summer for a few years.
Is herb robert deer resistant?
Yes. Deer rarely eat it, probably because of its strong smell, which is one reason it spreads so well in deer-browsed woods.
Why is it called stinky Bob?
The leaves release a sharp, unpleasant smell when crushed. It is harmless and washes off your hands.
Is it the same as a geranium from the garden center?
No. The red bedding "geraniums" sold in pots are Pelargoniums from South Africa. Herb Robert is a true hardy Geranium, related to garden cranesbills and native wild geranium.
What native plant can I grow instead?
In the East, wild geranium (Geranium maculatum), wild ginger and foamflower. In the Pacific Northwest, fringecup, piggyback plant, western wild ginger, inside-out flower and sword fern.
How does it spread so fast?
The long, beaked seed pods dry out and snap open, throwing seeds several feet. Seeds also stick to boots, fur and tires, and stay viable in the soil for a few years.
Is it poisonous?
It is not considered toxic to people or pets, and it has a long history in European folk medicine. That is not a reason to eat it or use it as a remedy.
How do I tell it from other wild geraniums?
Look for red, hairy stems, ferny leaves divided into stalked lobes, small pink flowers with pale stripes, and the strong smell. Shining geranium, another Northwest invader, has glossy, rounded leaves.
Can I compost it?
Plants pulled before flowering can go in a hot compost pile. Anything with flowers or seed pods should go in the trash, because seeds can survive a cool home compost bin.
Related PlantMapper tools & guides
Recommended products
Useful basics for clearing it and replanting with natives.
Product links go to search results on Amazon.com so you can compare options and prices. PlantMapper USA does not currently earn anything from these links. See our Affiliate Disclosure.
Find your next plant with PlantMapper
Shady spots fill up with weeds when nothing else is growing there. Tell us your soil, light and space and our free Plant Finder will suggest plants, including natives, that belong there.